BACnet/IP vs BACnet MS/TP

Two media for the same BMS protocol — how to choose.

Two media for BACnet

BACnet is based on a model of objects and services independent of the physical medium. This model travels either over BACnet/IP (Ethernet) or BACnet MS/TP (Master-Slave/Token-Passing over RS485). The objects (analog value, binary input…) are the same; only the network differs.

Side by side

BACnet/IP BACnet MS/TP
Medium Ethernet RS485
Speed 10/100 Mbit/s 9.6–115.2 kbaud
Access IP Token passing
Distance IP network ~1200 m over RS485
Wiring existing Ethernet 2-wire twisted pair
Inter-network BBMD BACnet router
Best for backbone, supervision field, HVAC devices

Which to choose, or mix them

BACnet/IP acts as the backbone and carries supervision; MS/TP serves the HVAC field at low wiring cost. In practice you combine them: MS/TP segments connected to an IP backbone through BACnet routers. The WBox gateway speaks both with the BACnet driver, and can route BACnet to MQTT or integrate Modbus and KNX.